It is the day before Valentine's Day in Dimmsdale and everyone is giving each other Valentine's gifts. Timmy decides that today was the day that he was going to ask Trixie to be his girlfriend. He goes and wishes that he had a fresh outfit and some more confidence. Cosmo, Poof, and Wanda grant the wish and Timmy goes to school and asks Trixie to be his girlfriend. Trixie says that she would never go out with Timmy, but she would rather go out with Chad. Timmy gets crushed and then decides to go home and use the computer. Timmy receives an IM from Veronica saying: Will you please be my Valentine?" Timmy replies by telling her that she would think about it. Cosmo says that Timmy shouldn't go out with Veronica because she is shallow, but Wanda says that Veronica is very nice and Timmy and she would make a great couple. Timmy IM's her back and tells her that he accepts her offer and they are each other's Valentine for tomorrow. When Timmy comes to school the next day he comes in with Veronica. Trixie gets jealous of Veronica and calls her a back-stabbing friend. She then tries all sorts of attempts to get Timmy and Veronica apart. When Timmy finally gets them to be apart, she kisses him and Timmy dumps Veronica and asks Trixie out. Trixie says that she doesn't want to be Timmy's girlfriend because he went out with Veronica and Timmy is left without a girlfriend.